At the moment I'm trying to prepare a grant application related to sport performance and recovery. The opening paragraph of my intial draft was:
A balance between training stressors and recovery are professed to be important in maximising the performance of athletes. Athlete training is generally based on a principal of progressive overload, in which the continual stress from adequate training stimulus leads to an adaptation process and subsequent improvement of performance. Although not well understood, it is thought that fatigue that prevents an athlete from performing at a perceived potential during training (generally based on a time and distance covered relationship) will result in suboptimal stress, and therefore reduced (is there any scientific evidence behind this idea??). Based on this understanding, recovery forms a crucial component of athlete preparation seeking peak performance.
So immediately I was looking for references to support that general understanding.
In fact most studies in the area make a similar comment, and I had noted that none of them were referenced. Normally you get a comment such as:
For example, it is a common belief that the flux through a metabolic pathway or a transport system may be a crucial factor determining subsequent adaptations in the contracting muscle (Bishop, 2009).
So I had a look, and couldn't find any. There appears to be a basic premise to all the literature on recovery and periodisation which isnt supported by scientific evidence. I'm not claiming its wrong, just pointing out its not supported in science. So I sort out some colleagues to see what they could tell me.
There is no doubt that some aspects of fatigue and inadequate recovery can be bad. Training and performance will obviously suffer with injury and illness or depleted fuel reserves. But how does fatigue influence the stimulus for adaptation from a specific bout of training?
So I invited a few colleagues to a Skype conversation and this is the response (edited for space and a few lines are bolded to give you an idea of what each part of the discussion is focussing on):
Ben Rattray (BR): question i need help with. any scientific evidence that fatigue and subsequent training performance (e.g. speed) is important 4 adaptation and improvement?
it makes sense, but is there any evidence? imagine training a bit tired, you don't run/ride quite as fast, but you try just as hard, and cardiovascular wise (HR), you might even get the same response. does the slower speed matter in terms of adaptation and improvement. chronic fatigue is a problem, but that is impeding on performance, what about fatigue impeding on training and the subsequent stimulus?
Tania Churchill (TC): Hmm... not sure if I can be of any help, but some initial thoughts: For a cyclist, fatigue decreases the amount of power than can be produced at the top end (not surprising, found one (Beelen & Sargeant, 1991). Conventional training wisdom is to not do sprint work when fatigued - not sure if there's research on this though. It does make sense- if power output is lower due to fatigue, then the training stimulus will be different, even if RPE is similar to when the athlete is fresh.
BR: yer agree makes sense. but does the lower power output mean there is less adaptation? (makes sense that it does, but I cant find any evidence).
what confuses this more is the recent research that shows there was similar expression of oxidative genes after interval and continuous exercise (overall duraton and work held constant) (Wang et al, 2009).
another study - provided you eat enough, then it may not matter training a bit tired? this study probably isnt long enough, they werent actually fatigued yet (fast swims at same pace) (Costill et al, 1988).
TC: Hmm... It might depend on the type of training while fatigued. I haven't found any studies on this yet, but if one goal of sprint training is to increase the efficiency of temporal sequencing of muscle activation, then presumably efforts at a lower speed wouldn't have the same effect.
Ben Wisbey (BW): without reading all of the above and with no research to back it up, I would suggest that high speed training is important to improve performance. especially in running based sports (cadence can make it a little more complicated for cyclists). You might get the same CV etc load when training fatigued, or training with heavy shoes, or doing hill repeats but the adaptation (especially neuromusc) are different. From a practical perspective you see it all the time. Eg. you orienteers are run fit and ultra strong uphill, but on the flat, performance is relatively low
The benefits you get are relative to the training you do. You need to revisit Noakes principles [e.g. Noakes, 2000 and Noakes et al, 2005]
BR: yer no i agree, completely. and yes Noakes talks about it. But no [?] evidence is presented. perhaps you can draw inferences from literature on overspeed training. but its not really the same thing. for instance, if you are tired (neuromuscular speaking) and you train as fast as you can, the neuromuscular system may still be "working as hard" as when you are fresh and running a bit faster. so is this "as hard" bit providing an equivalent training stimulus?
the temporal sequencing is still happening, just not quite as fast, but does this matter in terms of training stimulus when its working "as hard"?
TC: This might be useful - Merlau, 2005 - bit hard to tell from the abstract
BW: you are right Ben, no evidence. Maybe a good project for you
From a practical point of view, I think it is commonly accepted that speed training can only be maximised when fresh.
Cyclists do high cadence work or motor pacing
Distance runners do downhill sprints
Sprints and team sport athletes do overspeed work
All to get improvements in speed. This can't be achieved by running slow. Fatigued = slow.
Go research it and then tell us
BR: :) so recovery is all important for speed and speed only?
BW: don't understand the question. |-(
TC: Are other types of sessions (e.g. SE) still effective when fatigued?
BR: why do we get athletes so concerned about recovery if the only time it is important is when they are doing speed training?
BW: because speed (top end intensity) determines performance
Obviously recovery would be important for all sessions but the benefits of speed training dictate performance. Is a runner with a VO2 of 75 going to beat a runner with 70? Might help but only to a small degree. ??????? my opinions
BR: so im not clear on what you mean. you are saying, at the extreme, that Usian Bolt will beat Bekele in a marathon? clearly the top end intensity of these two athletes is very different. what do you mean my speed?
BW: sport relative speed
to run a marathon you need a base level of endurance. But beyond that base, is more better?
in cyclists and AFL players we have seen that a base level of endurance is required to perform well but above that and everyone is effectively similar. More is not better, but too little and performance suffers
BR: so if you are doing a session (flat, like on a track) you really need to be fresh for when you are running 110-130% race pace (say for a miler), but if you are doing a flat session at 80-100% race pace then recovery is less important. and its important because race specific speed is the most important part of performance.
so I've made up numbers, but is that your basic point?
BW: i would say you still need to be fresh at race pace otherwise you won't be able to hit and sustain that type of pace
remember you race when you are fresh
you see it all the time when athletes training for long events do volume and their intensity work slows and their short race performance slows
BR: that last example is a training specificity issue, not necessarily a fatigue issue.
Halson et al (2002) is anoter study that doesnt quite look at the issue. but they show that training with a lot of fatigue for a few weeks (and performance drops), after a recovery period they perform back at at least the same level. so there is a suggestion here that training whilst fatigue did not alter performance (but they didnt improve either, but there is an underlying assumption in the paper that they are already trained and therefore didnt antiicpate improved performance anyway... always assumptions).
BW: but it is event specific
and performance isn't going to change (up or down) substantially in athletes with a good training background
BR: yer that was my point, they are not likely to change anyway, but at least it suggests they didnt lose it even though they werent able to achieve the high power outputs.
event specific you mean cycling? and that doesnt relate to running?
BW: more mean that training while fatigued for a marathon is probably important for performance in some ways, while for a 800m, it is not
BR: ok, so recovery techniques for marathon runners are less important than for 800m runners?
TC: I think training for a long enduro race like a 24hr, some long aerobic sessions should be done while fatigued - but doesn't mean recovery techniques are less important. Just means fatigue is manupulated in different ways throughout a training week to the way a trackie would.
BW: yer good point. larger volumes mean you are always fatigued. but recovery is still important so that you can still manage maximum volume
TC: exactly
BR: so what are recovery techniques doing then? why are they helpful?
(clearly some advantages such as ensuring fuel, keeping immune system functioning)
but what say is cryotherapy doing? none of them?
BW: reducing inflamation and pain and allowing you to do it all again sooner
BR: so pain has obvious consequences for the pyschology of going out and doing it again. some level of inflammation is necessary for adaptation. so is it all just for the head?
TC: Presumably reducing inflammation and pain would have a positive effect on reducing likelihood of over-use injuries during the next training session?
BW: i hate your questions Ben
slushies reduced core temp in the lab and froze the girls in China as it was cold and wet
BR: inflammation is complex, too much bad, too little bad.
pretty sure the jury is out on who to reduce chronic injuries apart from reduced load.
so I started this by asking what evidence is there that training whilst tired will result in less of an adaptation, presumably through a "reduced training stimulus as measured by performance (e.g. speed). so we are agreeing there isnt any really, and that logically it makes sense, and emperically it matters more for shorter events than longer events. the exception to this is that adequate recovery makes athletes feel better, and this is important.
sums it up?
TC: Pretty much. I think some evidence will be out there - but it will be in bit and pieces. E.g. there will be evidence on the adaptations triggered by sprint training. And evidence on at what intensities certain adaptations are or aren't triggered.
And then there will be some stuff on periodisation. Doesn't seem to be so many studies here - more books like Bompa's (e.g. Bompa, 2009), which has lots of claims, but not much in the way of evidence.
So really we just concluded there was no evidence. There certainly seems to be a distinct lack of direct evidence, but inferences can probably be made from a range of studies, I have mentioned just two:
- in highly trained endurance athletes, high intensity training appears to improve performance without changes in cardiovascular parameters (VO2max etc) (Laursen & Jenkins, 2002)
- although, in relation to the above, high intensity training was shown to boost markers of oxidative metabolism, glycolysis and buffering capacity but with no improvement in performance - in rats (Laursen et al, 2007)
Admittedly since then I have found a couple, although the evidence is never direct. But that will have to wait for another post.
[...] Alfie wrote an interesting post today. Here’s a quick excerptBen Wisbey (BW): without reading all of the above and with no research to back it up, I would suggest that high speed training is important to improve performance. especially in running based sports (cadence can make it a little more complicated for cyclists). b…./b Possibly related posts: (automatically generated). F.A.C.T. Net · Menu for 9 February 2009 · Communicating in a Disaster: A Special Dinner Discussion. « bDiabetes research/b in the news … [...]
ReplyDeleteVery interesting post!
ReplyDeleteIt's funny how some things we just accept as true without much evidence behind it.
When reading this, I thought of a couple studies done where they had people train in a pre-fatigued state via manipulating the amount of time between exercise bouts.
Yeo, et al. 2008 Skeletal muscle adaptation and performance responses to once a day versus twice every second day endurance training regimens.
Skeletal muscle adaptation: training twice every second day vs. training once daily. Hansen AK, Fischer CP, Plomgaard P, Andersen JL, Saltin B, Pedersen BK.
J Appl Physiol. 2005 Jan;98(1):93-9. Epub 2004 Sep 10.
Cheers Steve,
ReplyDeleteI hadn't come across them. It seems a real task of cross referencing, and nothing directly linking chronic recovery or fatigue state and adaptation exists. at least its not obvious to me.
Hello everyone!
ReplyDeleteI would like to burn a theme at here. There is such a nicey, called HYIP, or High Yield Investment Program. It reminds of financial piramyde, but in rare cases one may happen to meet a company that really pays up to 2% daily not on invested money, but from real profits.
For several years , I earn money with the help of these programs.
I don't have problems with money now, but there are heights that must be conquered . I get now up to 2G a day , and my first investment was 500 dollars only.
Right now, I managed to catch a guaranteed variant to make a sharp rise . Visit my blog to get additional info.
http://theinvestblog.com [url=http://theinvestblog.com]Online Investment Blog[/url]
Good day, sun shines!
ReplyDeleteThere have were times of troubles when I felt unhappy missing knowledge about opportunities of getting high yields on investments. I was a dump and downright stupid person.
I have never imagined that there weren't any need in large starting capital.
Nowadays, I feel good, I begin take up real money.
It gets down to choose a proper companion who uses your money in a right way - that is incorporate it in real deals, parts and divides the profit with me.
You may ask, if there are such firms? I'm obliged to answer the truth, YES, there are. Please be informed of one of them:
http://theinvestblog.com [url=http://theinvestblog.com]Online Investment Blog[/url]
As much as I can understand right now, I think you're right!
ReplyDeleteNice work Ben.
ReplyDeleteI have a huge problem with ALL training studies because they assume everything else in the athlete's (subject's) life remains constant while the effects of the variable manipulation take place. For example, a researcher wants to measure the effect of hydrotherapy on reducing fatigue in trained athletes. They set up the study, identify the groups - i.e. the group doing the hydro and the control group. Set both groups a period of identical training (one group with hydro, the other without), re-measure both groups and if the hydro group show less fatigue, write it up (and present it at coaching conferences) that hydrotherapy reduce fatigue in athletes.
What about level of engagement in the training program of both groups?
What about even subtle differences in diet?
What about differences in technique and skills?
What about differences in the quality of sleep?
What about differences in training background between individual athletes?
What about differences in emotional state, e.g. personal conflicts in athletes' personal lives, financial issues?
What about subtle differences in compliance to the training and hydro therapies?
And - what about the huge jump between a tightly controlled research project and the real life of working with real people within for example a professional team environment?
So good on you for challenging the recovery zealotry that has swept the world.
Keep up the great work.
WG
http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=277184 online stock trading, stealsput, http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=277181 online stock trading, Pearryacuct ,http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=277182 bill bartmann, Eagedyglary, http://www.pyzam.com/profile/3328110 online stock trading, DyefPneunty, lypedopenenty, http://vjforums.com/member.php?u=17013 online stock trading, gidayerorry, http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=277056 online stock trading, Uriscisee, http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=277071 online stock trading, FuesyMumFoume
ReplyDelete1678g9q9
I don’t usually reply to posts but I will in this case, great info...I will add a backlink and bookmark your site. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteNice fill someone in on and this enter helped me alot in my college assignement. Say thank you you on your information.
ReplyDeleteI don’t usually reply to posts but I will in this case, great info...I will add a backlink and bookmark your site. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeletesurface encounters macomb
Hey, great blog...but I don’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me, please :)
ReplyDelete-Robert Shumake Paul Nicoletti
Your blog is so informative … ..I just bookmarked you....keep up the good work!!!!
ReplyDeleteHey, I found your blog in a new directory of blogs. I dont know how your blog came up, must have been a typo, anyway cool blog, I bookmarked you. :)
surface encounters mi
Your site was extremely interesting, especially since I was searching for thoughts on this subject last Thursday.
ReplyDeleteWho knows where can I download desktop virtual girls from here - VirtuagirlHD for free?? Is it possible? I've heard it is.
ReplyDeleteMature Mistress Ass
ReplyDeleteYoung Boy Fucks Mature Videos
Mature Fanny 2008 Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd
Matures On Top
Mature Women Giving Blowjob
Mature Pimpologist , Mature Lesbians Dvdrip Torrent Mature Bdsm Sites Free Mature Lesbian Hardcore Sex Mature Matijuana Plant Mature Big Pussys
Anus Mature 2008 Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd , Matures Gangraped Mature Cheating Home Vids Women Porn Sex Mature Boy Bdssm Free Mature Big Tit'S Slutty Mature Pics
Mature Busty Movies , Natural Mature Women Clips Mature Erotic Latina Mature Women Masturbating Movies Mature Orgy Free Pic Mature Plumper Porn Pics
Matures Rough Sexmilf Sex Long Movies , Matures In Slips Porn X Rated Mature Movies Mature Boys Sex Video Atk Mature Hairy Alle Busty Mature Gangbangs
Mature Hot Mammas , Mature Orgy Powered By Phpbb Mature Women Missionary Fucked Mature Women Porn Milf Utube Mature Sexy Porn Mature Puaay
Mature Home Video Porn Free , Mature Women In Hoose Mature Women And Younger Girls Xxx Full Bodied Sexy Mature Free Big Mature Tits Videos 50 Matures With Nylons
Mature Tiny Tgp , Mature Women Public Mature Cumshot Compilation Big Mature Ass And Pussy Pics Mature Wife At Home Vids Mature Squirt Movie
Bikini Mature Nudes , All Mature Gals Brittany Andrews Free Mature Peeing Porno Pictures Ebony Mature Pissing Slutty Mature Lesbians Redbook Mature Sex
Mature Maid Latino , Greasy Mature What Age Do Greyhounds Mature Mature Milf Xxx Dog Lick Mature Pussy Videos Mature Swingers In Masonville New Jersey
Mature Big Cock Lovers , Mature Cum Shots Videos Mature Wife Bisexual Mature White Women Young Men Stories Fat Mature Spunkers Twink Mature Gay Clips
Amiable dispatch and this post helped me alot in my college assignement. Say thank you you seeking your information.
ReplyDeleteSomeone deleted several links from iskladka and shared ...
ReplyDeleteFrom now, we will use www.tinyurlalternative.com as our main [url=http://www.tinyurlalternative.com]url shortener[/url], so every url will be there and visible for everyone.
You can pick out from several great [url=http://kfc.ms]short url[/url] address like:
kfc.ms easysharelink.info jumpme.info megauploadlink.info megavideolink.info mygamelink.info myrapidsharelink.info mytorrentlink.info myurlshortener.com mywarezlink.info urlredirect.info urlshrinker.info weblinkshortener.com youtubelink.info and many others.
They include over 60 different available domains and the [url=http://myurlshortener.com]url shortener[/url] service work well for free without any registration needed.
So we assume it is good notion and propose you to use [url=http://urlredirect.info]url redirect[/url] service too!
Thank you.
I mean that…
ReplyDelete---------------------------------------------------------
Signature:buy levitra professional online czh